FREE BOOKS

Author's List




PREV.   NEXT  
|<   507   508   509   510   511   512   513   514   515   516   517   518   519   520   521   522   523   524   525   526   527   528   529   530   531  
532   533   534   535   536   537   538   539   540   541   542   543   544   545   546   547   548   549   550   551   552   553   >>  
: "A man is sent to ride on a bicycle as fast as he can through the different streets. This invariably attracts attention. Boys and men follow him to the church, where it is easy to persuade them to enter." But this is an admission of our position in regard to the classes affected. The rabble may be Christianized by this means, but the intelligent will not be attracted.] [Footnote 44: After the greater part of our work had passed the final revision, and several months after the whole was gone to press, appeared Oldenberg's _Die Religion des Veda_, which, as the last new book on the subject, deserves a special note. The author here takes a liberal view, and does not hesitate to illustrate Vedic religion with the light cast by other forms of superstition. But this method has its dangers, and there is perhaps a little too much straining after original types, giant-gods as prototypes and totemism in proper names, where Vedic data should be separated from what may have preceded Vedic belief. Oldenberg, as a ritualist, finds in Varuna, Dawn, and the Burial Service the inevitable stumbling-blocks of such scholars as confuse Brahmanism with early Vedism. To remove these obstacles he suggests that Varuna, as the moon, was borrowed from the Semites or Akkadians (though be frankly admits that not even the shadow of this moon lingers in Vedic belief); explains Dawn's non-participation in _soma_ by stating that she never participates in it (which explains nothing); and jumps over the Burial Hymn with the inquiry whether, after all, it could not be interpreted as a cremation-hymn (the obvious answer being that the service does imply burial, and does not even hint at cremation). On the other hand, when theoretical barbarism and ritualism are foregone, Oldenberg has a true eye for the estimation of facts, and hence takes an unimpeachable position in several important particulars, notably in rejecting Jacobi's date of the Rig Veda; in rejecting also Hillebrandt's moon-_soma_; in denying an originally supreme Dy[=a]us; in his explanation of henotheism (substantially one with the explanation we gave a year ago); and in his account of the relation of the Rig Veda to the (later) Atharvan. Despite an occasional brilliant suggestion, which makes t
PREV.   NEXT  
|<   507   508   509   510   511   512   513   514   515   516   517   518   519   520   521   522   523   524   525   526   527   528   529   530   531  
532   533   534   535   536   537   538   539   540   541   542   543   544   545   546   547   548   549   550   551   552   553   >>  



Top keywords:
Oldenberg
 

Burial

 

cremation

 

explains

 
position
 

rejecting

 
Varuna
 

belief

 
explanation
 
participates

inquiry

 

interpreted

 

remove

 

obstacles

 

suggests

 
Vedism
 
scholars
 

confuse

 

Brahmanism

 
borrowed

Semites

 

lingers

 

participation

 

stating

 

shadow

 

admits

 

Akkadians

 

frankly

 
theoretical
 
henotheism

substantially

 
supreme
 

Hillebrandt

 

denying

 

originally

 

brilliant

 

occasional

 
suggestion
 

Despite

 
Atharvan

account

 

relation

 

Jacobi

 
notably
 
blocks
 

burial

 

answer

 

service

 

barbarism

 

ritualism