FREE BOOKS

Author's List




PREV.   NEXT  
|<   55   56   57   58   59   60   61   62   63   64   65   66   67   68   69   70   71   72   73   74   75   76   77   78   79  
80   81   82   83   >>  
eir own country. As the English have only a factory in this country, (for it is in the empire of the Great Mogul,) if we should admit this evidence [Gentoo evidence on a Gentoo oath], it would be agreeable to the genius of the law of England." For this he cites the proceedings of our Court of Admiralty, and adopts the author who states the precedent, "that this Court will give credit to the sentence of the Court of Admiralty in France, and take it to be according to right, and will not examine their proceedings: for it would be found very inconvenient, if one kingdom should, by peculiar laws, correct the judgments and proceedings of another kingdom." Such is the genius of the law of England, that these two principles, of the general moral necessities of things, and the nature of the case, overrule every other principle, even those rules which seem the very strongest. Chief-Baron Parker, in answer to an objection made against the infidel deponent, "that the plaintiff ought to have shown that he could not have the evidence of Christians," says, "that, repugnant to natural justice, in the Statute of Hue and Cry, the robbed is admitted to be witness of the robbery, as _a moral or presumed necessity is sufficient_." The same learned magistrate, pursuing his argument in favor of liberality, in opening and enlarging the avenues to justice, does not admit that "the authority of one or two cases" is valid against reason, equity, and convenience, the vital principles of the law. He cites Wells _v._ Williams, 1 Raymond, 282, to show that the necessity of trade has mollified the too rigorous rules of the old law, in their restraint and discouragement of aliens. "A Jew may sue at _this_ day, but _heretofore he could not_, for then they were looked upon as enemies, but now commerce has taught the world more humanity; and therefore held that an alien enemy, commorant here by the license of the King, and under his protection, may maintain a debt upon a bond, though he did not come with safe-conduct." So far Parker, concurring with Raymond. He proceeds:--"It was objected by the defendant's counsel, that this is a novelty, and that what never has been done ought not to be done." The answer is, "_The law of England is not confined to particular cases, but is much more governed by reason than by any one case whatever._ The true rule is laid down by Lord Vaughan, fol. 37, 38. 'Where the law,' saith he, 'is _known and clear_, the Judges must
PREV.   NEXT  
|<   55   56   57   58   59   60   61   62   63   64   65   66   67   68   69   70   71   72   73   74   75   76   77   78   79  
80   81   82   83   >>  



Top keywords:

evidence

 

proceedings

 

England

 

answer

 

necessity

 

country

 
kingdom
 

genius

 

Gentoo

 

principles


Admiralty

 

Parker

 
reason
 

justice

 

Raymond

 

commerce

 

humanity

 
taught
 
rigorous
 

restraint


mollified

 
discouragement
 

aliens

 
looked
 
heretofore
 

enemies

 

governed

 

confined

 
Judges
 

Vaughan


novelty

 

maintain

 

protection

 

license

 

conduct

 

objected

 

defendant

 

counsel

 

Williams

 
concurring

proceeds

 
commorant
 

robbery

 

inconvenient

 
peculiar
 

examine

 

sentence

 

France

 
correct
 

judgments