FREE BOOKS

Author's List




PREV.   NEXT  
|<   116   117   118   119   120   121   122   123   124   125   126   127   128   129   130   131   132   133   134   135   136   137   138   139   140  
141   142   143   >>  
political or literary controversy his mind was narrowly imprisoned in the opinions of his own or his father's age: and that is what makes him such an admirable witness to them; but here as elsewhere the life-giving quality in him lies in his hold on the universal human things which are affected by no controversies and belong to all the ages. None of his books exhibit more of what he himself calls "the two most engaging powers of an author." In it "new things are made familiar and familiar things are made new." The famous criticism of the "metaphysical poets" is so {224} written that a plain man feels at home in it: the thrice-told tale of the lives of Pope and Addison is so retold that every one thinks he reads it for the first time. The man who had in his earlier works sometimes seemed the most general and abstract even of eighteenth-century writers, becomes here, by force of his interest in the primary things of humanity, almost a pioneer of the new love of externalities, a relater of details, an anticipator of his own Boswell. To the critical discussions he gave less space than to the lives, and no one will pretend to wish he had done the opposite. Allusion has already been made to his limitations as a critic of poetry. He was blind to the most poetic qualities of the greatest men: the purest poetry, the poetry that has refined away all but the absolutely indispensable minimum of prose alloy, often escaped him altogether, sometimes simply irritated his prejudices. _Omne ignotum pro injucundo_. He found people enthusiastic admirers of Milton's _Lycidas_ or Gray's _Odes_, was angry at others enjoying what he found no pleasure in, and vented his temper on Gray and Milton. Though Collins was his friend he makes no mention of the _Ode to Evening_. In these cases and some others the critic is much less scrupulously fair than the biographer, to tell the truth, nearly {225} always is. There is perhaps a malicious touch here and there in the lives of Milton, Swift and Gray: but little as he liked any of them, how fairly in each case the good points of the man are brought out, and how they are left at the end quite overbalancing the rest in our memories! But in the case of their works it is different. He has little to say about Gray's _Elegy_, which he admired, and much about his _Odes_, which he disliked. Yet, in spite of some incapacity and some unfairness, Johnson's criticism of poetry is still a thing to be
PREV.   NEXT  
|<   116   117   118   119   120   121   122   123   124   125   126   127   128   129   130   131   132   133   134   135   136   137   138   139   140  
141   142   143   >>  



Top keywords:
things
 

poetry

 

Milton

 

familiar

 

critic

 
criticism
 
Collins
 

enthusiastic

 
admirers
 

people


injucundo

 

ignotum

 
Though
 

Lycidas

 
temper
 

vented

 
enjoying
 
disliked
 

pleasure

 

irritated


refined

 

absolutely

 

Johnson

 

purest

 

indispensable

 

minimum

 

altogether

 

incapacity

 

simply

 

friend


unfairness

 
escaped
 

prejudices

 

mention

 

greatest

 
overbalancing
 

malicious

 
brought
 

points

 
fairly

memories
 

scrupulously

 
Evening
 
biographer
 

admired

 

relater

 
engaging
 

powers

 
exhibit
 

author