FREE BOOKS

Author's List




PREV.   NEXT  
|<   1372   1373   1374   1375   1376   1377   1378   1379   1380   1381   1382   1383   1384   1385   1386   1387   1388   1389   1390   1391   1392   1393   1394   1395   1396  
1397   1398   1399   1400   1401   1402   1403   1404   1405   1406   1407   1408   1409   1410   1411   1412   1413   1414   1415   1416   1417   1418   1419   1420   1421   >>   >|  
"His _arm only_ was bare," there is no adverb; and, where he afterwards speaks of the latitude allowable in the placing of adverbs, alleging, "It is indifferent whether we say, 'He bared his _arm only_;' or, 'He bared _only_ his arm,'" the word _only_ is an adjective, in one instance, if not in both. With this writer, and some others, the syntax of an adverb centres mainly in the suggestion, that, "_It's_ propriety and force depend on _it's_ position."--_Ib._, p. 147. Illustration: "Thus people commonly say; '_I only_ spoke three words:' which properly implies, that _I_, and _no other person_, spoke three words: when the intention of the speaker requires: 'I spoke _only three_ words; that is, _no more than three_ words.'"--_Ib._, p. 327. One might just as well say, "I spoke three words _only_." But the interpretation above is hypercritical, and contrary to that which the author himself gives in his note on the other example, thus: "Any other situation of the adverb would make a difference. 'He _only_ bared his arm;' would imply, that he did _nothing more than_ bare his arm. '_Only_ he bared his arm;' must refer to a preceding part of the sentence, stating something, to which the act of baring his arm was an exception; as, 'He did it in the same manner, _only_ he bared his arm.' If _only_ were placed immediately before _arm_; as, '_He_ bared his _only arm_;' it would be an adjective, and signify, that he had but one arm."--_Ib._, p. 328. Now are not, "_I only spoke three words_," and, "_He only bared his arm_," analogous expressions? Is not the former as good English as the latter? _Only_, in both, is most naturally conceived to belong to the verb; but either may be read in such a manner as to make it an adjective belonging to the pronoun. OBS. 28.--The term _not but_ is equivalent to two negatives that make an affirmative; as, "_Not but_ that it is a wide place."--_Walker's Particles_, p. 89. "_Non_ quo _non_ latus locus sit."--_Cic. Ac._, iv, 12. It has already been stated, that _cannot but_ is equal to _must_; as, "It is an affection which _cannot but_ be productive of some distress."--_Blair's Rhet._, p. 461. It seems questionable, whether _but_ is not here an adverb, rather than a conjunction. However this may be, by the customary (but faulty) omission of the negative before _but_, in some other sentences, that conjunction has acquired the adverbial sense of _only_; and it may, when used with that signification, be
PREV.   NEXT  
|<   1372   1373   1374   1375   1376   1377   1378   1379   1380   1381   1382   1383   1384   1385   1386   1387   1388   1389   1390   1391   1392   1393   1394   1395   1396  
1397   1398   1399   1400   1401   1402   1403   1404   1405   1406   1407   1408   1409   1410   1411   1412   1413   1414   1415   1416   1417   1418   1419   1420   1421   >>   >|  



Top keywords:

adverb

 

adjective

 
manner
 

conjunction

 

pronoun

 

belonging

 

affirmative

 

negatives

 

equivalent

 
belong

expressions
 

analogous

 

English

 
Walker
 
conceived
 

naturally

 

However

 
customary
 

questionable

 
faulty

omission

 
signification
 
adverbial
 

negative

 

sentences

 

acquired

 
affection
 

productive

 

distress

 
stated

Particles
 

allowable

 

properly

 

implies

 

placing

 

adverbs

 

commonly

 

indifferent

 

alleging

 
latitude

person
 
speaks
 

requires

 

intention

 

speaker

 
people
 

centres

 

suggestion

 

syntax

 

writer