FREE BOOKS

Author's List




PREV.   NEXT  
|<   742   743   744   745   746   747   748   749   750   751   752   753   754   755   756   757   758   759   760   761   762   763   764   765   766  
767   768   769   770   771   772   773   774   775   776   777   778   779   780   781   782   783   784   785   786   787   788   789   790   791   >>   >|  
besides being awkward, is incorrect, and _does not express the idea intended_. This will be obvious, I think, from the following considerations. "1. The expression, '_is being_,' is equivalent to '_is_,' and expresses no more; just as, '_is loving_,' is equivalent to, '_loves_.' Hence, '_is being built_,' is precisely equivalent to, '_is built_.' "2. '_Built_,' is a perfect participle; and therefore cannot, in any connexion, express an action, or the suffering of an action, _now in progress_. The verb _to be_, signifies _to exist_; '_being_,' therefore, is equivalent to '_existing_.' If then we substitute the synonyme, the nature of the expression will be obvious; thus, 'the house is _being built_,' is, in other words, 'the house is _existing built_,' or more simply as before, 'the house _is built_;' plainly importing an action not progressing, but now _existing in a finished state_. "3. If the expression, '_is being built_,' be a correct form of the present indicative passive, then it must be equally correct to say in the perfect, '_has been being built_;' in the past perfect, '_had been being built_;' in the present infinitive,'_to be being built_;' in the perfect infinitive,'_to have been being built_;' and in the present participle, '_being being built_;' which all will admit to be expressions as incorrect as they are inelegant, but precisely analogous to that which now begins to prevail."--_Bullions's Principles of English Gram._, p. 58. OBS. 6.--It may be replied, that the verbs _to be_ and _to exist_ are not always synonymous; because the former is often a mere auxiliary, or a mere copula, whereas the latter always means something positive, as _to be in being, to be extant_. Thus we may speak of a thing as _being destroyed_, or may say, it _is annihilated_; but we can by no means speak of it as _existing destroyed_, or say, it _exists annihilated_. The first argument above is also nugatory. These drawbacks, however, do not wholly destroy the force of the foregoing criticism, or at all extenuate the obvious tautology and impropriety of such phrases as, _is being, was being_, &c. The gentlemen who affirm that this new form of conjugation "_is being introduced_ into the language," (since they allow participles to follow possessive pronouns) may very fairly be asked, "What evidence have you of _its being being introduced_?" Nor can they, on their own principles, either object to the monstrous phraseology of thi
PREV.   NEXT  
|<   742   743   744   745   746   747   748   749   750   751   752   753   754   755   756   757   758   759   760   761   762   763   764   765   766  
767   768   769   770   771   772   773   774   775   776   777   778   779   780   781   782   783   784   785   786   787   788   789   790   791   >>   >|  



Top keywords:

existing

 

equivalent

 

perfect

 

present

 

action

 

expression

 

obvious

 

annihilated

 

introduced

 
incorrect

correct

 
express
 
infinitive
 

destroyed

 
precisely
 

participle

 

extant

 

copula

 
destroy
 

wholly


monstrous

 

drawbacks

 

argument

 
phraseology
 
exists
 

nugatory

 

positive

 

extenuate

 

language

 

participles


fairly

 
pronouns
 

possessive

 

follow

 

evidence

 

auxiliary

 

conjugation

 

tautology

 
principles
 

impropriety


foregoing
 
criticism
 

phrases

 

affirm

 

gentlemen

 

object

 

expressions

 
connexion
 

suffering

 
progress