FREE BOOKS

Author's List




PREV.   NEXT  
|<   747   748   749   750   751   752   753   754   755   756   757   758   759   760   761   762   763   764   765   766   767   768   769   770   771  
772   773   774   775   776   777   778   779   780   781   782   783   784   785   786   787   788   789   790   791   792   793   794   795   796   >>   >|  
rogressive used passively,--that is, of not always denoting _continuance in the state of receiving continued action_,--and which is, for that remarkable reason, judged worthy of _rejection_, is nevertheless admitted to have, in very many instances, a conformity to this idea, and therefore to "belong [thus far] to the present tense."--P. 103. This contradicts to an indefinite extent, the proposition for its rejection. It is observable also, that the same examples, '_I am loved_' and 'I _am smitten_,'--the same "_tolerated, but erroneous forms_," (so called on page 103,) that are given as specimens of what he would reject,--though at first pronounced "_equivalent_ in grammatical construction," censured for the same pretended error, and proposed to be changed alike to "_the true form_" by the insertion of "_being_,"--are subsequently declared to "belong to" different classes and different tenses. "_I am loved_," is referred to that "numerous" class of verbs, which "_detail_ ACTION _of prior, but retained, endured, and continued existence_; and therefore, in this sense, _belong to the present tense_." But "_I am smitten_," is idly reckoned of an opposite class, (said by Dr. Bullions to be "perhaps the greater number,") whose "ACTIONS described are neither _continuous_ in their nature, nor _progressive_ in their duration; but, on the contrary, _completed_ and _perfected_; and [which] are consequently descriptive of _passed_ time and ACTION."--_Wright's Gram._, p. 103. Again: "In what instance soever this latter form and signification _can_ be introduced, _their import should be, and, indeed, ought to be, supplied by the perfect tense construction_:--for example, '_I am smitten_,' [should] be, '_I have been smitten_.'"--_Ib._ Here is self-contradiction indefinitely extended _in an other way_. Many a good phrase, if not every one, that the author's first suggestion would turn to the unco-passive form, his present "_remedy_" would about as absurdly convert into "the perfect tense." OBS. 14.--But Wright's inconsistency, about this matter, ends not here: it runs through all he says of it; for, in this instance, error and inconsistency constitute his whole story. In one place, he anticipates and answers a question thus: "To what tense do the constructions, 'I am pleased;' 'He is expected;' '_I am smitten_;' 'He is bound;' belong?" "We answer:--_So far as_ these and like constructions are applicable to the delineation of _continuou
PREV.   NEXT  
|<   747   748   749   750   751   752   753   754   755   756   757   758   759   760   761   762   763   764   765   766   767   768   769   770   771  
772   773   774   775   776   777   778   779   780   781   782   783   784   785   786   787   788   789   790   791   792   793   794   795   796   >>   >|  



Top keywords:

smitten

 

belong

 

present

 

Wright

 

ACTION

 

perfect

 

inconsistency

 

construction

 

instance

 
continued

constructions

 
rejection
 
indefinitely
 

descriptive

 
extended
 

contradiction

 

signification

 

completed

 
perfected
 

soever


import

 

introduced

 

supplied

 
passed
 
convert
 

answers

 

question

 

anticipates

 

constitute

 

pleased


expected

 
applicable
 

delineation

 

continuou

 

answer

 

passive

 

remedy

 

suggestion

 
author
 

phrase


absurdly
 
contrary
 

matter

 

retained

 

observable

 

proposition

 

extent

 
contradicts
 

indefinite

 
examples