FREE BOOKS

Author's List




PREV.   NEXT  
|<   227   228   229   230   231   232   233   234   235   236   237   238   239   240   241   242   243   244   245   246   247   >>  
: beta]) who doth not follow us, and we forbad him ([Symbol: alpha]) because he followeth not us.' Here the authority for [Symbol: alpha] is [Symbol: Aleph]BCL[Symbol: Delta], four Cursives, f, Bohairic, Peshitto, Ethiopic, and the Lewis MS. For [Symbol: beta] there are D, two Cursives, all the Old Latin but f and the Vulgate. For the Traditional Text, i.e. the whole passage, A[Symbol: Phi][Symbol: Sigma]N + eleven Uncials, all the Cursives but six, the Harkleian (yet obelizes [Symbol: alpha]) and Gothic versions, Basil (ii. 252), Victor of Antioch (Cramer, Cat. i. 365), Theophylact (i. 219): and Augustine quotes separately both omissions ([Symbol: alpha] ix. 533, and [Symbol: beta] III. ii. 153). No other Fathers, so far as I can find, quote the passage. Dr. Hort appears to advance no special arguments on his side, relying apparently upon the obvious repetition. In the first part of the verse, St. John describes the case of the man: in the second he reports for our Lord's judgement the grounds of the prohibition which the Apostles gave him. Is it so certain that the original text of the passage contained only the description, and omitted the reason of the prohibition as it was given to the non-follower of our Lord? To me it seems that the simplicity of St. Mark's style is best preserved by the inclusion of both. The Apostles did not curtly forbid the man: they treated him with reasonableness, and in the same spirit St. John reported to his Master all that occurred. Besides this, the evidence on the Traditional side is too strong to admit of it not being the genuine reading. (4) St. Mark ix. 49. 'For ([Symbol: alpha]) every one shall be salted with fire, ([Symbol: beta]) and every sacrifice shall be salted with salt.' The authorities are-- [Symbol: alpha]. [Symbol: Aleph]BL[Symbol: Delta], fifteen Cursives, some MSS. of the Bohairic, some of the Armenian, and the Lewis. [Symbol: beta]. D, six copies of the Old Latin, three MSS. of the Vulgate. Chromatius of Aquileia (Galland. viii. 338). Trad. Text. AC[Symbol: Phi][Symbol: Sigma]N and twelve more Uncials, all Cursives except fifteen, two Old Latin, Vulgate, Peshitto, Harkleian, some MSS. of Ethiopic and Armenian, Gothic, Victor of Antioch (Cramer's Cat. i. 368), Theophylact (i. 221). This evidence must surely be conclusive of the genuineness of the Traditional reading. But now for Dr. Hort. 'A reminiscence of Lev. vii
PREV.   NEXT  
|<   227   228   229   230   231   232   233   234   235   236   237   238   239   240   241   242   243   244   245   246   247   >>  



Top keywords:

Symbol

 

Cursives

 

passage

 

Vulgate

 
Traditional
 
Cramer
 

Antioch

 

Victor

 

Armenian

 

fifteen


salted

 

prohibition

 

Apostles

 

evidence

 

reading

 

Theophylact

 

Ethiopic

 
Peshitto
 

Bohairic

 

Uncials


Harkleian
 
Gothic
 

treated

 

forbid

 

genuineness

 

surely

 

spirit

 
Aquileia
 

reasonableness

 

conclusive


simplicity

 
preserved
 

curtly

 
Galland
 

reminiscence

 

inclusion

 
occurred
 
copies
 

follower

 

Chromatius


twelve

 

authorities

 

sacrifice

 

Besides

 

reported

 

Master

 
strong
 

genuine

 
Augustine
 

quotes