FREE BOOKS

Author's List




PREV.   NEXT  
|<   87   88   89   90   91   92   93   94   95   96   97   98   99   100   101   102   103   104   105   106   >>  
and necessary for the preservation of decorum and for the respectability of the profession." Marshall C. J. 9 Wheat. 531. [4] Per Gibson, C. J., in Austin's case, 5 Rawle, 204. [5] The exact weight of one hundred silver dollars of the old coinage is 85.9375 ounces; of the new coinage, 80 ounces. [6] _Ex parte_ Carter, 1 Philada. Rep. 507. Blaike's Lessee _v._ Chambers, 1 Serg. & Rawle, 169. [7] Court and juries have their respective spheres assigned to them, within which each is to act and move, without encroaching upon the jurisdiction or province of the other. In order, then, that jurors as well as others may know that the direction and decision of the court, on any question of law arising in the course of the trial of an issue of fact, is not to be disregarded, and that a verdict given against such direction, whatever it may be, can never avail anything, unless it be to occasion additional delay, trouble, and expense to the parties, as also to the public, the course of the court is to set the verdict aside, and to order a new trial. And a court, from whose decisions on questions of law, an appeal lies, by writ of error or otherwise, ought never to depart from this course; otherwise the party against whom the verdict is given loses the benefit of such appeal, and of having the question decided by the Appellate Court, which would be a most unjust and illegal deprivation of his right. Per Kennedy, J., in Flemming _v._ Marine Ins. Co. 4 Whart. 67. After two concurring verdicts against the direction of the court in point of law, a new trial will still be awarded. Commissioners of Berks County _v._ Ross, 3 Binn. 520. "Principles the most firmly established might be overturned, because a second jury were obstinate and rash enough to persevere in the errors of the first, in a matter confessed by all to be properly within the jurisdiction of the court; I mean the construction of the law arising from undisputed facts." Per Tilghman, C. J., Ibid. 524. It is not necessary to refer to the numerous cases, both in the English and American courts, which accord with these principles. A judicious selection of the leading ones is to be found in the note to 1 Wharton's Troubat & Haly, 529. The text and the note are confined, of course, to civil cases. [8] Burnet's Life of Sir Matthew Hale, 72. [9] An attorney is not answerable for every error or mistake; he ought not to be liable, in cases of reasonable doubt. Pitt _v._ Yald
PREV.   NEXT  
|<   87   88   89   90   91   92   93   94   95   96   97   98   99   100   101   102   103   104   105   106   >>  



Top keywords:

direction

 

verdict

 
jurisdiction
 

appeal

 

arising

 

question

 

ounces

 

coinage

 

persevere

 

Flemming


Kennedy
 

liable

 

Marine

 

reasonable

 

concurring

 

errors

 

awarded

 

Commissioners

 

County

 

Principles


verdicts

 

overturned

 

firmly

 

established

 

obstinate

 

mistake

 

leading

 

Wharton

 

selection

 
judicious

principles

 
Troubat
 

Burnet

 

Matthew

 

confined

 

accord

 

courts

 

construction

 

undisputed

 

properly


matter

 

confessed

 

Tilghman

 

attorney

 

answerable

 

English

 

American

 
numerous
 

public

 

Chambers