FREE BOOKS

Author's List




PREV.   NEXT  
|<   147   148   149   150   151   152   153   154   155   156   157   158   159   >>  
SOCRATES: If, then, a syllable is a whole, and has many parts or letters, the letters as well as the syllable must be intelligible and expressible, since all the parts are acknowledged to be the same as the whole? THEAETETUS: True. SOCRATES: But if it be one and indivisible, then the syllables and the letters are alike undefined and unknown, and for the same reason? THEAETETUS: I cannot deny that. SOCRATES: We cannot, therefore, agree in the opinion of him who says that the syllable can be known and expressed, but not the letters. THEAETETUS: Certainly not; if we may trust the argument. SOCRATES: Well, but will you not be equally inclined to disagree with him, when you remember your own experience in learning to read? THEAETETUS: What experience? SOCRATES: Why, that in learning you were kept trying to distinguish the separate letters both by the eye and by the ear, in order that, when you heard them spoken or saw them written, you might not be confused by their position. THEAETETUS: Very true. SOCRATES: And is the education of the harp-player complete unless he can tell what string answers to a particular note; the notes, as every one would allow, are the elements or letters of music? THEAETETUS: Exactly. SOCRATES: Then, if we argue from the letters and syllables which we know to other simples and compounds, we shall say that the letters or simple elements as a class are much more certainly known than the syllables, and much more indispensable to a perfect knowledge of any subject; and if some one says that the syllable is known and the letter unknown, we shall consider that either intentionally or unintentionally he is talking nonsense? THEAETETUS: Exactly. SOCRATES: And there might be given other proofs of this belief, if I am not mistaken. But do not let us in looking for them lose sight of the question before us, which is the meaning of the statement, that right opinion with rational definition or explanation is the most perfect form of knowledge. THEAETETUS: We must not. SOCRATES: Well, and what is the meaning of the term 'explanation'? I think that we have a choice of three meanings. THEAETETUS: What are they? SOCRATES: In the first place, the meaning may be, manifesting one's thought by the voice with verbs and nouns, imaging an opinion in the stream which flows from the lips, as in a mirror or water. Does not explanation appear to be of this nature? THEAETETUS: Certa
PREV.   NEXT  
|<   147   148   149   150   151   152   153   154   155   156   157   158   159   >>  



Top keywords:

SOCRATES

 

THEAETETUS

 

letters

 

syllable

 

syllables

 

meaning

 

opinion

 

explanation

 

elements

 

Exactly


experience
 

knowledge

 

learning

 
perfect
 
unknown
 
talking
 

nonsense

 
intentionally
 

unintentionally

 

stream


proofs

 

simple

 

letter

 

indispensable

 

nature

 

subject

 

belief

 

mirror

 

thought

 

choice


meanings
 
manifesting
 
definition
 

imaging

 

mistaken

 

question

 

rational

 

statement

 
argument
 
equally

Certainly

 

expressed

 
inclined
 

disagree

 
remember
 

intelligible

 
expressible
 

acknowledged

 

undefined

 
reason