FREE BOOKS

Author's List




PREV.   NEXT  
|<   149   150   151   152   153   154   155   156   157   158   159   >>  
not. SOCRATES: And do you not remember that in your case and in that of others this often occurred in the process of learning to read? THEAETETUS: You mean that I mistook the letters and misspelt the syllables? SOCRATES: Yes. THEAETETUS: To be sure; I perfectly remember, and I am very far from supposing that they who are in this condition have knowledge. SOCRATES: When a person at the time of learning writes the name of Theaetetus, and thinks that he ought to write and does write Th and e; but, again, meaning to write the name of Theododorus, thinks that he ought to write and does write T and e--can we suppose that he knows the first syllables of your two names? THEAETETUS: We have already admitted that such a one has not yet attained knowledge. SOCRATES: And in like manner be may enumerate without knowing them the second and third and fourth syllables of your name? THEAETETUS: He may. SOCRATES: And in that case, when he knows the order of the letters and can write them out correctly, he has right opinion? THEAETETUS: Clearly. SOCRATES: But although we admit that he has right opinion, he will still be without knowledge? THEAETETUS: Yes. SOCRATES: And yet he will have explanation, as well as right opinion, for he knew the order of the letters when he wrote; and this we admit to be explanation. THEAETETUS: True. SOCRATES: Then, my friend, there is such a thing as right opinion united with definition or explanation, which does not as yet attain to the exactness of knowledge. THEAETETUS: It would seem so. SOCRATES: And what we fancied to be a perfect definition of knowledge is a dream only. But perhaps we had better not say so as yet, for were there not three explanations of knowledge, one of which must, as we said, be adopted by him who maintains knowledge to be true opinion combined with rational explanation? And very likely there may be found some one who will not prefer this but the third. THEAETETUS: You are quite right; there is still one remaining. The first was the image or expression of the mind in speech; the second, which has just been mentioned, is a way of reaching the whole by an enumeration of the elements. But what is the third definition? SOCRATES: There is, further, the popular notion of telling the mark or sign of difference which distinguishes the thing in question from all others. THEAETETUS: Can you give me any example of such a definition? SOCRATES:
PREV.   NEXT  
|<   149   150   151   152   153   154   155   156   157   158   159   >>  



Top keywords:

SOCRATES

 

THEAETETUS

 

knowledge

 

opinion

 

explanation

 

definition

 

letters

 

syllables

 

learning

 

remember


thinks

 

combined

 

maintains

 
rational
 

prefer

 

perfect

 
adopted
 
remaining
 

explanations

 

difference


telling

 

popular

 
notion
 

distinguishes

 

question

 

speech

 

expression

 

fancied

 

mentioned

 

enumeration


elements

 

reaching

 

attain

 

manner

 

attained

 

condition

 

person

 

enumerate

 

fourth

 

supposing


knowing

 

admitted

 

Theaetetus

 
Theododorus
 

meaning

 

suppose

 

writes

 

process

 
friend
 
united