FREE BOOKS

Author's List




PREV.   NEXT  
|<   54   55   56   57   58   59   60   61   62   63   64   >>  
te: Necessary to understand foreign juristic methods.] 75. In worse plight than even the employment of foreign literature is the understanding of foreign juristic methods. And yet without such an understanding the gates are thrown open for misconceptions, for unfounded claims, and for mutual recriminations. How great is the divergence of juristic method can only be appreciated by one who has practised and been called to the teaching of law in different countries. Now, just as the outlook of its people is incorporated in the law of every state, so the specific mode of thought and the logical attitude of any given people are mirrored in its juristic methods. Historical tradition, political interdependence, and other accidental influences do indeed also play a great part therein, but the fundamental factor is the difference of modes of thought and points of view. Seeing, then, that the law of nations is one and the same for every member of the community of states, but that on the other hand the science of every state elaborates the law of nations on the basis of its national juristic methods, it is unavoidable that discord should arise if the science of international law of individual states neglect to acquaint itself with foreign juristic methods. It is not only in scientific treatises, but also in judicial decisions, that expression is given to these methods, and the discordance between judicial decisions on the same issue given in different states is often traceable simply to the difference of juristic method. That the law is essentially the same is no guarantee that in all countries there will be a unanimity of judicial pronouncement on every point thereof. If ever--and it is not outside the range of practical possibility--an international agreement, including all states, were arrived at concerning all the topics of the so-called international private law and international criminal law, there would, for the reason under consideration, still continue to be no security that the same law would in every point receive the same treatment from the courts of all countries. In order to attain this end there would have to be an international tribunal erected above the municipal courts of all states, and its judgments would have to be accepted as binding by the municipal courts concerned. It is just for this reason that the proposed International Prize Court and the proposed permanent court for international disputes will aim in
PREV.   NEXT  
|<   54   55   56   57   58   59   60   61   62   63   64   >>  



Top keywords:
juristic
 

methods

 

international

 
states
 

foreign

 

countries

 
courts
 

judicial

 

people

 
decisions

science

 

reason

 

nations

 
called
 
difference
 

thought

 

municipal

 

understanding

 
proposed
 

method


simply

 

concerned

 

traceable

 

International

 

binding

 

continue

 

guarantee

 

judgments

 

accepted

 

essentially


treatises

 

scientific

 
disputes
 

permanent

 

consideration

 
discordance
 

expression

 

receive

 

arrived

 

attain


including

 

possibility

 
agreement
 

treatment

 

topics

 
practical
 

pronouncement

 
tribunal
 
unanimity
 
criminal