FREE BOOKS

Author's List




PREV.   NEXT  
|<   102   103   104   105   106   107   108   109   110   111   112   113   >>  
essity, or as a matter of fact, dolichocephalic skulls had anything to do with Aryan, mesophalic with Semitic, or brachycephalic with Turanian speech, was nothing but the wildest random thought. It could convey no rational meaning whatever; we might as well say that all painters were dolichocephalic, and all musicians brachycephalic, or that all lophocomic tribes worked in gold, and all lisocomic tribes in silver. If anything must be ascribed to prehistoric times, surely the differentiation of the human skull, the human hair and the human skin would have to be ascribed to that distant period. No one, he believed, had ever maintained that a mesocephalic skull was split or differentiated into a dolichocephalic and a brachycephalic variety in the bright sunshine of history. Nevertheless, he had felt for years that knowledge of languages must be considered in future as a _sine qua non_ for every anthropologist. How few of the books in which we trusted with regard to the characteristic peculiarities of savage races had been written by men who had lived among them for ten or twenty years, and who had learned their languages till they could speak them as well as the natives themselves. It was no excuse to say that any traveler who had eyes to see and ears to hear could form a correct estimate of the doings and sayings of savage tribes. TRAVELERS' IMPRESSIONS. It was not so, as anthropologists knew from sad experience. Suppose a traveler came to a camp where he saw thousands of men and women dancing round the image of a young bull. Suppose that the dancers were all stark naked, that after a time they began to fight, and that at the end of their orgies there were three thousand corpses lying about weltering in their blood. Would not a casual traveler have described such savages as worse than the negroes of Dahomey? Yet these savages were really the Jews, the chosen people of God. The image was the golden calf, the priest was Aaron, and the chief who ordered the massacre was Moses. We might read the 32d chapter of Exodus in a very different sense. A traveler who could have conversed with Aaron and Moses might have understood the causes of the revolt and the necessity of the massacre. But without this power of interrogation and mutual explanation, no travelers, however graphic and amusing their stories might be, could be trusted; no statements of theirs could be used by the anthropologist for truly scientific purposes. If ant
PREV.   NEXT  
|<   102   103   104   105   106   107   108   109   110   111   112   113   >>  



Top keywords:
traveler
 

tribes

 

brachycephalic

 
dolichocephalic
 

languages

 

savage

 

Suppose

 

ascribed

 

savages

 

trusted


massacre

 
anthropologist
 

casual

 
weltering
 
thousand
 

corpses

 

thousands

 

dancing

 

experience

 

dancers


orgies

 

ordered

 

interrogation

 

mutual

 

explanation

 
understood
 

revolt

 

necessity

 

travelers

 

scientific


purposes

 

graphic

 
amusing
 

stories

 

statements

 

conversed

 

people

 

chosen

 

golden

 

negroes


Dahomey
 
priest
 

Exodus

 

chapter

 

twenty

 
differentiation
 

surely

 
lisocomic
 
silver
 

prehistoric