FREE BOOKS

Author's List




PREV.   NEXT  
|<   608   609   610   611   612   613   614   615   616   617   618   619   620   621   622   623   624   625   626   627   628   629   630   631   632  
633   634   635   636   637   638   639   640   641   642   643   644   645   646   647   648   649   650   651   652   653   654   655   656   657   >>   >|  
chance represent actual existences; while science terminates in concepts or laws, themselves not possibly existent, but verified by recurring particular facts, belonging to the same experience as those from which the theory started. [Sidenote: Platonic status of hypothesis.] The laws formulated by science--the transitive figments describing the relation between fact and fact--possess only a Platonic sort of reality. They are more real, if you will, than the facts themselves, because they are more permanent, trustworthy, and pervasive; but at the same time they are, if you will, not real at all, because they are incompatible with immediacy and alien to brute existence. In declaring what is true of existences they altogether renounce existence on their own behalf. This situation has made no end of trouble in ill-balanced minds, not docile to the diversities and free complexity of things, but bent on treating everything by a single method. They have asked themselves persistently the confusing question whether the matter or the form of things is the reality; whereas, of course, both elements are needed, each with its incommensurable kind of being. The material element alone is existent, while the ideal element is the sum of all those propositions which are true of what exists materially. Anybody's _knowledge_ of the truth, being a complex and fleeting feeling, is of course but a moment of existence or material being, which whether found in God or man is as far as possible from being that truth itself which it may succeed in knowing. [Sidenote: Meaning of verification.] The true contrast between science and myth is more nearly touched when we say that science alone is capable of verification. Some ambiguity, however, lurks in this phrase, since verification comes to a method only vicariously, when the particulars it prophesies are realised in sense. To verify a theory as if it were not a method but a divination of occult existences would be to turn the theory into a myth and then to discover that what the myth pictured had, by a miracle, an actual existence also. There is accordingly a sense in which myth admits substantiation of a kind that science excludes. The Olympic hierarchy might conceivably exist bodily; but gravitation and natural selection, being schemes of relation, can never exist substantially and on their own behoof. Nevertheless, the Olympic hierarchy, even if it happened to exist, could not be proved
PREV.   NEXT  
|<   608   609   610   611   612   613   614   615   616   617   618   619   620   621   622   623   624   625   626   627   628   629   630   631   632  
633   634   635   636   637   638   639   640   641   642   643   644   645   646   647   648   649   650   651   652   653   654   655   656   657   >>   >|  



Top keywords:

science

 

existence

 
existences
 

theory

 

verification

 
method
 

things

 

material

 
element
 

Sidenote


Platonic

 

actual

 

existent

 

Olympic

 
reality
 

relation

 

hierarchy

 

behoof

 

substantially

 

ambiguity


capable

 

contrast

 

touched

 

Nevertheless

 

proved

 

moment

 

succeed

 

knowing

 

happened

 
Meaning

prophesies

 

miracle

 

bodily

 
pictured
 
gravitation
 
discover
 

conceivably

 

admits

 
substantiation
 

excludes


feeling

 
natural
 
particulars
 
realised
 

schemes

 

vicariously

 
phrase
 

verify

 

selection

 

occult