FREE BOOKS

Author's List




PREV.   NEXT  
|<   903   904   905   906   907   908   909   910   911   912   913   914   915   916   917   918   919   920   921   922   923   924   925   926   927  
928   929   930   931   932   933   934   935   936   937   938   939   940   941   942   943   944   945   946   947   948   949   950   951   952   >>   >|  
th all human interior principles are corrupted. Therefore also the intellect itself is corrupted. Obj. 2: Further, the human soul is hindered from understanding when the senses are tied, and by a distracted imagination, as explained above (Q. 84, AA. 7,8). But death destroys the senses and imagination, as we have shown above (Q. 77, A. 8). Therefore after death the soul understands nothing. Obj. 3: Further, if the separated soul can understand, this must be by means of some species. But it does not understand by means of innate species, because it has none such; being at first "like a tablet on which nothing is written": nor does it understand by species abstracted from things, for it does not then possess organs of sense and imagination which are necessary for the abstraction of species: nor does it understand by means of species, formerly abstracted and retained in the soul; for if that were so, a child's soul would have no means of understanding at all: nor does it understand by means of intelligible species divinely infused, for such knowledge would not be natural, such as we treat of now, but the effect of grace. Therefore the soul apart from the body understands nothing. _On the contrary,_ The Philosopher says (De Anima i, 1), "If the soul had no proper operation, it could not be separated from the body." But the soul is separated from the body; therefore it has a proper operation and above all, that which consists in intelligence. Therefore the soul can understand when it is apart from the body. _I answer that,_ The difficulty in solving this question arises from the fact that the soul united to the body can understand only by turning to the phantasms, as experience shows. Did this not proceed from the soul's very nature, but accidentally through its being bound up with the body, as the Platonists said, the difficulty would vanish; for in that case when the body was once removed, the soul would at once return to its own nature, and would understand intelligible things simply, without turning to the phantasms, as is exemplified in the case of other separate substances. In that case, however, the union of soul and body would not be for the soul's good, for evidently it would understand worse in the body than out of it; but for the good of the body, which would be unreasonable, since matter exists on account of the form, and not the form for the sake of matter. But if we admit that the nature of the soul re
PREV.   NEXT  
|<   903   904   905   906   907   908   909   910   911   912   913   914   915   916   917   918   919   920   921   922   923   924   925   926   927  
928   929   930   931   932   933   934   935   936   937   938   939   940   941   942   943   944   945   946   947   948   949   950   951   952   >>   >|  



Top keywords:

understand

 

species

 

Therefore

 

separated

 

nature

 

imagination

 

matter

 
proper
 
operation
 
difficulty

phantasms

 

things

 

turning

 

abstracted

 

intelligible

 

Further

 

understands

 

understanding

 
senses
 

corrupted


accidentally

 

proceed

 

intellect

 
Platonists
 

experience

 

question

 

arises

 

solving

 
distracted
 

answer


united

 

vanish

 

exists

 

substances

 
evidently
 
separate
 

account

 

hindered

 

removed

 

return


exemplified

 

simply

 

unreasonable

 

organs

 
possess
 

abstraction

 

retained

 

principles

 
interior
 

written