leverness or in awkwardness of
expression. But so far as substantial additions are concerned they
present only doctrinaire statements of a purely theoretical nature or
elaborations, which belong to the realm of political metaphysics. To
enter upon them here is unnecessary. Let us confine ourselves to the
completed work, the Declaration as it was finally determined after long
debate in the sessions from the twentieth to the twenty-sixth of
August.[32]
FOOTNOTES:
[Footnote 18: "De la necessite d'etablir quels sont les droits de
l'homme et des citoyens, et d'en faire une declaration qu'ils puissent
opposer a toutes les especes d'injustice."--_Archives parlementaires I.
Serie_, IV, pp. 161 _et seq._]
[Footnote 19: _Archives parl._, V, pp. 281 _et seq._]
[Footnote 20: _Arch. parl._, VIII, pp. 221, 222.]
[Footnote 21: _Cf. e.g._ H. v. Sybel, _Geschichte der Revolutionszeit
von 1789 bis 1800, 4. Aufl._, I, p. 73.]
[Footnote 22: _Cf._ Haeusser, _Geschichte der franz. Revolution, 3.
Aufl._, p. 169; H. Schulze, _Lehrbuch des deutschen Staatsrechts_, I, p.
368; Stahl, _Staatslehre, 4. Aufl._, p. 523; Taine, _loc. cit._: _La
revolution_, I, p. 274: "Ici rien de semblable aux declarations precises
de la Constitution americaine." In addition, note 1: _cf. la Declaration
d'independance du 4 juillet 1776_.]
[Footnote 23: Stahl, _loc. cit._, p. 524; Taine, _loc. cit._ The fact
that Jefferson's proposal to enact a declaration of rights was rejected
is expressly emphasized in a note.]
[Footnote 24: Stahl, _loc. cit._, p. 523, does mention, in addition, the
declarations of the separate states, but he does not specify when they
originated, nor in what relation they stand to the French Declaration,
and his comments show that he is not at all familiar with them. Janet,
_loc. cit._, I, p. v _et seq._, enters at length into the subject of the
state declarations in order to show the originality of the French, and
he even makes the mistaken attempt to prove French influence upon the
American (p. xxxv). The more detailed history of the American
declarations he is quite ignorant of.]
[Footnote 25: _Memoires, correspondances et manuscripts du general
Lafayette, publies par sa famille_, II, p. 46.]
[Footnote 26: "Mais les constitutions que se donnerent successivement
les treize etats, furent precedees de declarations des droits, dont les
principes devaient servir de regles aux representans du peuple, soit aux
conventions, soit
|