FREE BOOKS

Author's List




PREV.   NEXT  
|<   41   42   43   44   45   46   47   48   49   50   51   >>  
eed to give the tools to him who can handle them; that government does by no means go on of itself, but more than anything else in this world demands skill, patience, energy, long and tenacious grip, and the constant presence of that most indispensable, yet most rare, of all practical convictions, that the effect is the inevitable consequent of the cause. Here was a revolution, we cannot doubt. The French Revolution was in a manner a complement to it, as Mr. Carlyle himself says in a place where he talks of believing both in the French Revolution and in Frederick; 'that is to say both that Real Kingship is eternally indispensable, and also that the destruction of Sham Kingship (a frightful process) is occasionally so.'[18] It is curious that an observer who could see the positive side of Frederick's disruption of Europe in 1740, did not also see that there was a positive side to the disruption of the French monarchy fifty years afterwards, and that not only was a blow dealt to sham kingship, but a decisive impulse was given to those ideas of morality and justice in government, upon which only real kingship in whatever form is able to rest. [17] _History of Frederick the Great_, iv. 328. See also vol. i., Proem. [18] _Frederick the Great_, i. 9. * * * * * As to the other great factor in the dissolution of the old state, the decay of ancient spiritual forms, Mr. Carlyle gives no uncertain sound. Of the Reformation, as of the French Revolution, philosophers have doubted how far it really contributed to the stable progress of European civilisation. Would it have been better, if it had been possible, for the old belief gradually as by process of nature to fall to pieces, new doctrine as gradually and as normally emerging from the ground of disorganised and decayed convictions, without any of that frightful violence which stirred men's deepest passions, and gave them a sinister interest in holding one or other of the rival creeds in its most extreme, exclusive, and intolerant form? This question Mr. Carlyle does not see, or, if he does see it, he rides roughshod over it. Every reader remembers the notable passage in which he declares that the question of Protestant or not Protestant meant everywhere, 'Is there anything of nobleness in you, O Nation, or is there nothing?' and that afterwards it fared with nations as they did, or did not, accept this sixteenth century form of Truth when it
PREV.   NEXT  
|<   41   42   43   44   45   46   47   48   49   50   51   >>  



Top keywords:
French
 

Frederick

 
Revolution
 

Carlyle

 
indispensable
 
kingship
 
gradually
 

question

 

convictions

 

disruption


government

 

process

 

positive

 

frightful

 

Kingship

 

Protestant

 

pieces

 

nature

 

belief

 

civilisation


uncertain

 

Reformation

 

philosophers

 

ancient

 
spiritual
 
doubted
 

doctrine

 

European

 

progress

 

contributed


stable

 
passions
 
declares
 

nobleness

 

passage

 

notable

 

reader

 

remembers

 

sixteenth

 
accept

century
 
nations
 

Nation

 

roughshod

 
violence
 

stirred

 

deepest

 

decayed

 

emerging

 
ground