FREE BOOKS

Author's List




PREV.   NEXT  
|<   131   132   133   134   135   136   137   138   139   140   141   142   143   144   145   146   147   148   >>  
loc. cit. ante_, p. 413. [126] Belt, _Naturalist in Nicaragua_, p. 119. [127] Buechner, _Geistesleben der Thiere_, p. 318. I could prolong this list to a much greater length, but think it hardly necessary. I think that I have demonstrated that man is not the only tool-user. Even such dyed-in-the-wool creationists as Kirby and Spence are forced to admit the presence of reason in insects. "Such, then, are the exquisiteness, the number, and the extraordinary development of the instincts of insects. But is instinct the sole guide of their actions? Are they in every case the blind agent of irresistible impulse? These queries, I have already hinted, cannot, in my opinion, be replied to in the affirmative; and I now proceed to show that though instinct is the chief guide to insects, they are endowed also with no inconsiderable portion of _reason_."[128] [128] Kirby and Spence, _Entomology_, p. 591. Studied both objectively and subjectively, insects present indisputable evidence of reason. Not the higher abstract reason of the human being, however, but reason in its primal, fundamental state. The difference between instinct and reason is not generally understood, and, as I believe that most readers can comprehend an illustration much quicker than an explanation, I will use the former in order to bring out this difference. The hen which sits three weeks on a china egg is influenced by blind impulse--instinct; while the turkey which discovers the eggs of her rival in her nest, and destroys them, is directed by something infinitely higher--by reason. The using of a common nest never occurs among these birds in a wild state, neither is it of so frequent occurrence among domesticated turkeys as to have formed an instinctive habit. Again, the honey-making ants which left their patrol line in order to slay the wounded centipede may have been, and probably were, influenced by instinct; another and wholly different psychical trait, however, impelled them to fill up the trench dug with my hunting knife. This accident could not have occurred, perhaps, to them in a state of nature, or if by any possibility it had ever occurred before, the chances are that such occurrences were few in number, and that they happened at long intervals of time, thus precluding the establishment of an instinctive habit. Nor do I think it possible for this action to come under the head of "specialized instinct," for the same reason. B
PREV.   NEXT  
|<   131   132   133   134   135   136   137   138   139   140   141   142   143   144   145   146   147   148   >>  



Top keywords:

reason

 

instinct

 

insects

 

occurred

 

influenced

 

Spence

 

number

 

impulse

 

higher

 

difference


instinctive

 

infinitely

 

precluding

 

common

 

establishment

 

turkeys

 

domesticated

 

occurs

 
frequent
 

directed


occurrence

 
destroys
 

specialized

 

action

 

turkey

 

discovers

 

trench

 

chances

 

occurrences

 
impelled

hunting
 

accident

 

possibility

 

psychical

 
patrol
 
making
 
intervals
 

nature

 
wounded
 

happened


wholly

 

centipede

 

formed

 

fundamental

 

presence

 

exquisiteness

 

forced

 

creationists

 

extraordinary

 

development