FREE BOOKS

Author's List




PREV.   NEXT  
|<   298   299   300   301   302   303   304   305   306   307   308   309   310   311   312   313   314   315   316   317   318   >>  
ng the capture of Lord Grey, the Monk adds, "which we grieve to say." The MS., without any such, expression of sympathy or sorrow, says that "he fell into the snare which he had prepared for others."[317] [Footnote 317: In the MS. the word is "lacum," probably a mistake for "laqueum."] 4. The Monk merely records the return of Isabel to France; the MS. reflects strongly on her return _without her dower_, and her feelings of repugnance against receiving any boon from Henry, whom she regarded as _Richard's enemy_. 5. Speaking of the battle of Homildon, the Monk says, "Of _our countrymen_ only five were slain;" and adds, "We praise thee, O God, because thou hast been mindful of us." The MS. says, "_And of the English_ scarcely five were slain;" but adds no word of praise. 6. The Monk says, "From this time Owyn's cause seemed to grow (p. 430) and prosper, _ours_ to decrease." This is omitted in the MS. 7. Whereas the Monk (describing the character of Richard in the very words--and many are unusual words--adopted by the MS.) records that Richard was in the habit of sitting throughout the night till the morning in drinking, and "other occupations not to be named:" the MS. omits the latter phrase. The Monk says there were _two_ points of excellence in Richard's character; the MS., though confining itself to the two specified by the Monk, calls them "very many," "_plura_." 8. In recording the commencement of Owyn Glyndowr's rebellion, the Monk, speaking of it as "an execrable revolt," says that the Welsh elected Owyn against the principles of peace [contra pacem elegerunt]. The MS. says that the Welsh elected a respectable and venerable gentleman to be their leader and prince. Our attention is now especially called to some points in which the MS. seems to be so full of historical mistakes and improbabilities as to render any statement of a fact, especially of an improbable fact, not supported by other evidence, suspicious.[318] [Footnote 318: The Author on the whole is rather disposed to think that, whilst the Monk records accurately what fell within his own knowledge, both he and the author of the Sloane MS. in this part borrowed from some common document, probably more than one; for in some points they vary from each other in a way best
PREV.   NEXT  
|<   298   299   300   301   302   303   304   305   306   307   308   309   310   311   312   313   314   315   316   317   318   >>  



Top keywords:

Richard

 

records

 

points

 
character
 

return

 

Footnote

 

praise

 

elected

 

speaking

 
elegerunt

revolt

 
principles
 
rebellion
 

contra

 
execrable
 

excellence

 

confining

 

phrase

 
recording
 
commencement

respectable

 
Glyndowr
 

disposed

 

common

 
whilst
 

Author

 

document

 
accurately
 

knowledge

 

author


Sloane

 

borrowed

 

suspicious

 

evidence

 

attention

 

called

 

prince

 

gentleman

 

leader

 

render


statement

 

improbable

 
supported
 

improbabilities

 

historical

 

mistakes

 

venerable

 
feelings
 

repugnance

 

receiving