to put it into real estate, and he said he would!" repeated
the old lady wearily.
"But, madam, you do not answer my question!" exclaimed Chanler. "How
much did you give him?"
"I told him to put it into real--" began the old lady again.
"Yes, yes!" cried the lawyer; "we know that! Answer the question."
"estate, and he said he would!" finished the old woman innocently.
"If your Honor please, I will excuse the witness. And I move that her
answers be stricken out!" cried Chanler savagely.
The old lady was assisted from the stand, but as she made her way
with difficulty towards the door of the court-room she could be heard
repeating stubbornly:
"I told him to put it into real estate, and he said he would!"
Almost needless to say, Hackett was convicted and sentenced to seven
years in State's prison.
To recapitulate, the quickness and positiveness of women make them
ordinarily better witnesses than men; they are vastly more difficult to
cross-examine; their sex protects them from many of the most effective
weapons of the lawyer, with the result that they are the more ready to
yield to prevarication; and, even where the possibility of complete
and unrestricted cross-examination is afforded, their tendency to
inaccurately inferential reasoning, and their elusiveness in dodging
from one conclusion to another, render the opportunity of little value.
In general, however, women's testimony differs little in quality
from that of men, all testimony being subject to the same three great
limitations irrespective of the sex of the witness, and the conclusions
set forth above are merely the result of an effort on the part of the
writer to comment somewhat upon those small differences which, under
close scrutiny, may fairly be said to exist. These differences are quite
as noticeable at the breakfast-table as in the court-room; and are
no more patent to the advocate than to the ordinary male animal whose
forehead habitually reddens when he hears the unanswerable reason which,
in default of all others, explains and glorifies the mental action of
his wife, sister or mother: "Just because!"
AS COMPLAINANTS AND DEFENDANTS
The ratio of women to men indicted and tried for crime is, roughly,
about one to ten. Could adequate statistics be procured, the proportion
of female to male complainants in criminal cases would very likely prove
to be about the same: In a very substantial proportion, therefore, of
all prosecutions
|