FREE BOOKS

Author's List




PREV.   NEXT  
|<   94   95   96   97   98   99   100   101   102   103   104   105   106   107   >>  
usion at all. This was the last note of the Victorians: procrastination was called progress. Now if we look for the worst fruits of this fallacy we shall find them in historical criticism. There is a curious habit of treating any one who comes before a strong movement as the "forerunner" of that movement. That is, he is treated as a sort of slave running in advance of a great army. Obviously, the analogy really arises from St. John the Baptist, for whom the phrase "forerunner" was rather peculiarly invented. Equally obviously, such a phrase only applies to an alleged or real divine event: otherwise the forerunner would be a founder. Unless Jesus had been the Baptist's God, He would simply have been his disciple. Nevertheless the fallacy of the "forerunner" has been largely used in literature. Thus men will call a universal satirist like Langland a "morning star of the Reformation," or some such rubbish; whereas the Reformation was not larger, but much smaller than Langland. It was simply the victory of one class of his foes, the greedy merchants, over another class of his foes, the lazy abbots. In real history this constantly occurs; that some small movement happens to favour one of the million things suggested by some great man; whereupon the great man is turned into the running slave of the small movement. Thus certain sectarian movements borrowed the sensationalism without the sacramentalism of Wesley. Thus certain groups of decadents found it easier to imitate De Quincey's opium than his eloquence. Unless we grasp this plain common sense (that you or I are not responsible for what some ridiculous sect a hundred years hence may choose to do with what we say) the peculiar position of Stevenson in later Victorian letters cannot begin to be understood. For he was a very universal man; and talked some sense not only on every subject, but, so far as it is logically possible, in every sense. But the glaring deficiencies of the Victorian compromise had by that time begun to gape so wide that he was forced, by mere freedom of philosophy and fancy, to urge the neglected things. And yet this very urgency certainly brought on an opposite fever, which he would not have liked if he had lived to understand it. He liked Kipling, though with many healthy hesitations; but he would not have liked the triumph of Kipling: which was the success of the politician and the failure of the poet. Yet when we look back up the false perspecti
PREV.   NEXT  
|<   94   95   96   97   98   99   100   101   102   103   104   105   106   107   >>  



Top keywords:

forerunner

 
movement
 
Reformation
 

phrase

 
Victorian
 
simply
 
Baptist
 

things

 

universal

 

Unless


Langland
 

running

 

Kipling

 

fallacy

 
success
 
responsible
 

politician

 

failure

 

ridiculous

 
hundred

hesitations
 

healthy

 

choose

 

triumph

 
common
 

decadents

 

perspecti

 
sacramentalism
 

Wesley

 
groups

easier
 

eloquence

 

imitate

 

Quincey

 

subject

 
forced
 

freedom

 

philosophy

 

talked

 
deficiencies

glaring

 

logically

 

neglected

 

understand

 
letters
 

Stevenson

 

position

 
compromise
 

peculiar

 

understood