FREE BOOKS

Author's List




PREV.   NEXT  
|<   41   42   43   44   45   46   47   48   49   50   51   52   53   54   55   56   57   58   59   60   61   62   63   64   65  
66   67   68   69   >>  
lds as an element of the Latin,"-- he could not have known that the same writer has, in the sixth volume of the _Classical Museum_, continued the comparison at great length; and as that work falls into the hands of but few, I shall transcribe some passages which may throw light on the subject: "It has for some years been recognised, at least by several English scholars, that there is a remarkable similarity between the Celtic languages and Latin. In the case of Welsh it was, I believe, at first supposed that the words must have been introduced by the Roman dominion in Britain; but when the likeness was found to exist in the Erse, and that the Erse was even more like to Latin (as regards the consonants) than the Welsh is, this idea of course fell to {358} the ground. The scholar and physiologist, who pressed into notice the strong similarities of the Celtic to the European languages, and claimed a place for Celtic within that group, Dr. Prichard, has naturally fixed his attention with so much strength on the _primitive_ relations of all these tongues, as to be jealous and suspicious of an argument, which alleges that the one has borrowed from the other. Some ten years ago, by his favour, I read a MS. of a vocabulary (the composition of Dr. Stratton, formerly of Aberdeen), which compared the Gaelic with the Latin tongue in alphabetical order without comment or development. From this vocabulary Prichard gives an extract in his chapter on the Italian nations, and finds it entirely to confirm his views that the Roman language has not suffered any larger admixture by a foreign action. What is or was Dr. Stratton's opinion, I never heard. His vocabulary first suggested to me the value of this inquiry, and that is all. Having now been led to a fuller examination of the Welsh and Gaelic dictionaries, I find not only a far greater abundance of material (especially in the Welsh) than I could have imagined; but also, that by grouping words aright, conclusions result such as I had not expected, and adverse to those of Dr. Prichard." Professor Newman, as T. H. T. has observed, confined himself to a tabular view of Celtic and Latin words; but the grammatical structure and formal development of the two languages have not been overlooked in the philological literature of England. These interesting inquiries have been pursued by Dr
PREV.   NEXT  
|<   41   42   43   44   45   46   47   48   49   50   51   52   53   54   55   56   57   58   59   60   61   62   63   64   65  
66   67   68   69   >>  



Top keywords:

Celtic

 

vocabulary

 

Prichard

 

languages

 

development

 
Stratton
 

Gaelic

 

suffered

 
language
 

confirm


opinion

 

admixture

 

action

 
larger
 

foreign

 
Aberdeen
 

compared

 

tongue

 
composition
 

favour


alphabetical

 

extract

 

chapter

 

Italian

 

nations

 

comment

 

pursued

 

expected

 
adverse
 

philological


aright

 
literature
 

conclusions

 

result

 

Professor

 

Newman

 

formal

 

tabular

 

grammatical

 

confined


overlooked

 

observed

 

grouping

 
fuller
 

examination

 

dictionaries

 
structure
 
Having
 

inquiries

 

inquiry